Don't get me wrong, I am not here to bash Portis.
If we did not have Portis, we would have been down in the dumps during the Gibbs II era. We did not have a passing threat and we had at best a mediocre O line. Defenses put 8 men in the box and Gibbs just ran Portis over and over.
When Gibbs traded a future Hall of Famer Champ Bailey and a 2nd rounder for Portis, he was going to get his moneys worth. Portis on the other hand was constantly hurt because of overuse. His yards per carry went down. He also has become overtly careful regarding a few fumbles he had earlier and started putting two hands on the ball. In my view that took quite a bit away from his running.
Now Portis, who has been great warrior for the Redskins for a long time is at a point where many running backs of his caliber get to. He still has some gas left in his tank but the team is just not good enough for him to really be productive. You put Portis in a team like Patriots or Colts and he will give a 1200 to 1400 yards season. But you put him in our offense he will barely get to a 1000 yards rushing and he will take lot more hits from the linebackers rather than secondaries.
I just don't see the burst of speed that Portis used to have right now. Betts is hitting the holes with heck of a speed and making the 1st guy miss a lot of the times. He is also a better pass catcher than Portis and defenses has to account for that. Jim Zorn already said that he would not like to make Portis a second stringer right now given the fact that he has produced for such a long time. I'd argue that, in case of running backs it's imperative that you make him a second stringer because of the same reason. This kind of production in such circumstances has taken a toll on the man and it's Zorn's duty to promote Betts and save Portis's health.
Sitting Portis
The Steelers didn't have any trouble sitting Willie Parker when he got hurt, and Mendenhall is doing just fine for them. You can throw back, like Zorn is doing, and say injury won't make you lose your starting job. But let's face it, winning teams make good decisions and sometimes that hurts people's feeling, even veterans who have helped you in the past. Like Sonny Corleone said, "it's not personal, it's business".
Totally agreed
Jim Zorn being a former player in the NFL has some preconcived ideas that hurts him as a coach. This is one of those that he does not want to replace a started because he got hurt. The most famous example of starter getting replaced by a backup is Tom Brady.
clarify
I should clarify here. What I meant was Tom Brady replaced injured starter Drew Bledsoe. When Bledsoe came back from injury he did not get his job back. Actually, same thing happened to Joe Montana as well. He did not get his job back after he was replaced by Steve Young after winning multiple superbowls.
Brady came in as the
Brady came in as the replacement for Drew Bledsoe
Not Brady exactly
Brady got his job back so not sure of that as an example. Also the examples of replacing a prominent star are very different when it comes to running backs. Look at Addai and Edgerrin James. There are a host of running backs out there that lost their starting job and went on to be good elsewhere. I don't think it's over for Portis but his time in Washington has to end. Betts while not as gifted as Portis just may be the right back for us at this time (in the Stephen Davis mode).
Any back that runs into his blockers as much as Portis does is obviously not making firm decisions to hit one hole. Betts does a great job of picking the right gap and sticking it (yes I realize how that could be read)